Ackee
New search

5833 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Here's 5833 Winthrop Avenue in Indianapolis, IN 46220. This listing is closed, but I can still walk you through the details.

1 photo from the listing — tap any to expand.

Front exterior at 5833 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, INRecently Sold — 5833 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 462201 / 1

Quick read on the numbers:

$625,000

Recently Sold
Beds

4

Baths

2

Sq ft

2,553

Built

1936

Acres

0.2

Here's what I think this home is worth:

FREE FROM SHELDON

Thinking about your next move?

Most people checking their own home's value are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — see how I price, market, and sell homes in Carmel and Hamilton County.

Explore selling with Ackee

Key things to know

  • Sold 4.0% over list in 2 days
  • Fireplace
  • Basement
  • Forest Hills subdivision

From the listing

Welcome home to 5833 Winthrop Ave in the coveted Forest Hills neighborhood. This 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home has been lovingly updated over the years while maintaining the character of this esteemed neighborhood. The home is situated upon a hill with gorgeous landscaping leading you to the front entry and an inviting brick patio. Upon entry, you're greeted by original tile flooring in the entry and natural hardwood flooring throughout most of the main level. The living room features an arched built in bookshelf, gas fireplace and tons of natural light. The inviting dining room is prominent for family gatherings and located just off the galley kitchen. The wood paneled sitting room provides an additional area for friends and family. Off the dining room, the updated galley kitchen is well appointed with ample granite countertops and soft close drawers. There are three nicely sized bedrooms with natural hardwood floors and a cheeky full bathroom. Upstairs you will find an owner's paradise featuring a large loft area, bathroom with double sinks, glassed in shower and a dream of a closet. Don't miss the extra attic space off the closet! The basement is awaiting your vision for an addition…

A few highlights from the feature list:

Interior

Attic AccessBuilt-in FeaturesHardwood FloorsWalk-In Closet(s)

I'll break the details down — open any section that matters.

This home has sold:

Sold

$650,000

+$25,000 over list (4.0%)

Closed
Jun 2, 2026
Listed at
$625,000
Sold
2 weeks ago
Sold in
2 days

Price history

  1. Sold$650,000

    Jun 2, 2026

  2. Listedat $625,000

    May 1, 2026

Forest Hills · activity

past 6 months

Sold
10
Median price
$662,000
Median DOM
7 days

A few similar homes that recently sold nearby:

Recent comparable sales

Same zip · similar size

  • 5744 Spruce Knoll Court

    $290,000

    5744 Spruce Knoll Court

    3bd · 3ba · 2,035 sqft

    Sold Jun 2026

  • 5215 E 62nd Street

    $454,000

    5215 E 62nd Street

    3bd · 3ba · 3,120 sqft

    Sold Jun 2026

  • 4865 Kessler Boulevard East Drive

    $380,000

    4865 Kessler Boulevard East Drive

    3bd · 4ba · 3,113 sqft

    Sold Jun 2026

  • 5303 Broadway Street

    $677,000

    5303 Broadway Street

    4bd · 4ba · 2,971 sqft

    Sold Jun 2026

  • 6830 N Delaware Street

    $700,000

    6830 N Delaware Street

    3bd · 2ba · 2,404 sqft

    Sold Jun 2026

Comparative value

5 comps in this range

This home is 43% above median for similar nearby sales.

$290K$700KMedian $454K
$650K

A few places to dig deeper:

Forest Hills Indianapolis Public Schools

MLS# 22099055

Explore homes in Indianapolis

By bedroom count

  • 2-bedroom homes in Indianapolis
  • 3-bedroom homes in Indianapolis
  • 4-bedroom homes in Indianapolis
  • 5-bedroom homes in Indianapolis
  • 6-bedroom homes in Indianapolis

By price

  • Indianapolis homes under $500k
  • Indianapolis homes $500k – $750k
  • Indianapolis homes $750k – $1m
  • Indianapolis homes $1m – $2m
  • Indianapolis homes over $2m

By feature

  • Indianapolis homes with a pool
  • Indianapolis homes with a garage
  • Indianapolis homes new construction

By home type

  • Single-family homes in Indianapolis
  • Condos in Indianapolis
  • Townhouses in Indianapolis

Nearby cities

  • Homes for sale in Camby
  • Homes for sale in Beech Grove
  • Homes for sale in Speedway
  • Homes for sale in Lawrence