Ackee
New search

5556 W Stinemyer Road, New Palestine, IN 46163

Here's 5556 W Stinemyer Road in New Palestine, IN 46163. This listing is closed, but I can still walk you through the details.

1 photo from the listing — tap any to expand.

Showing 1 of 25 · 24 more loading.

Front exterior at 5556 W Stinemyer Road, New Palestine, INRecently Sold — 5556 W Stinemyer Road, New Palestine, IN 461631 / 1

Quick read on the numbers:

$339,900$389,900

Recently Sold
Beds

3

Baths

2

Sq ft

1,795

Built

2001

Acres

0.79

Here's what I think this home is worth:

FREE FROM SHELDON

Thinking about your next move?

Most people checking their own home's value are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — see how I price, market, and sell homes in Carmel and Hamilton County.

Explore selling with Ackee

Key things to know

  • Sold 18% below list in 195 days
  • Fireplace
  • Stinemyer Crossing subdivision

From the listing

Feast your eyes on the delightful single-family residence at 5556 W Stinemyer RD, NEWPALESTINE, IN, where the charm of country living meets modern convenience, all nestled in Hancock county, ready for you to make it your own! Imagine sinking into the embrace of your living room, where the crackling fireplace casts a warm glow upon the beamed and vaulted ceiling, creating a sanctuary where stories are shared and memories are made under that high ceiling. The kitchen, complete with a kitchen bar and kitchen peninsula, is the ideal place to whip up culinary masterpieces or simply enjoy a casual breakfast as the sun streams through the windows. Then there's a bedroom with crown molding, the final touch of elegance to complete the room. This property includes two full bathrooms and a laundry room, providing plenty of space for everyone to get ready in the mornings. The porch offers the perfect spot for sipping sweet tea and watching the world go by. With three bedrooms and a generous 1795 square feet of living space set upon a sprawling 34543 square foot lot, this is more than just a house; it's a place where dreams take root and blossom.

A few highlights from the feature list:

Interior

Breakfast BarCathedral Ceiling(s)Ceiling VaultedEat-in KitchenWalk-In Closet(s)

Exterior

Playset

I'll break the details down — open any section that matters.

This home has sold:

Sold

$320,000

-$69,900 below list (-17.9%)

Closed
May 8, 2026
Listed at
$389,900
Sold
1 week ago
Sold in
195 days

Price history

  1. Sold$320,000

    May 8, 2026

  2. Price reduced$344,900 → $339,900

    Mar 31, 2026

  3. Listedat $389,900

    Sep 13, 2025

Stinemyer Crossing · activity

past 6 months

Sold
2
Median price
$362,000
Median DOM
195 days

A few similar homes that recently sold nearby:

Recent comparable sales

Same zip · similar size

  • 4678 W Otway Lane

    $340,000

    4678 W Otway Lane

    3bd · 2ba · 1,904 sqft

    Sold May 2026

  • 3779 S Village Row

    $340,000

    3779 S Village Row

    3bd · 2ba · 1,503 sqft

    Sold May 2026

  • 4746 W 1110 N

    $174,000

    4746 W 1110 N

    3bd · 2ba · 1,268 sqft

    Sold Apr 2026

  • 3902 W 300 S

    $262,000

    3902 W 300 S

    3bd · 2ba · 2,017 sqft

    Sold May 2026

  • 6251 W 300 S

    $329,000

    6251 W 300 S

    3bd · 3ba · 1,624 sqft

    Sold May 2026

Comparative value

5 comps in this range

This home is 2.7% below median for similar nearby sales.

$174K$340KMedian $329K
$320K

A few places to dig deeper:

Stinemyer Crossing Southern Hancock Co Com Sch Corp

MLS# 22062650

Explore homes in New Palestine

By bedroom count

  • 2-bedroom homes in New Palestine
  • 3-bedroom homes in New Palestine
  • 4-bedroom homes in New Palestine
  • 5-bedroom homes in New Palestine
  • 6-bedroom homes in New Palestine

By price

  • New Palestine homes under $500k
  • New Palestine homes $500k – $750k
  • New Palestine homes $750k – $1m
  • New Palestine homes $1m – $2m
  • New Palestine homes over $2m

By feature

  • New Palestine homes with a pool
  • New Palestine homes with a garage
  • New Palestine homes new construction

By home type

  • Single-family homes in New Palestine
  • Condos in New Palestine
  • Townhouses in New Palestine

Nearby cities

  • Homes for sale in Greenfield
  • Homes for sale in McCordsville
  • Homes for sale in Fortville
  • Homes for sale in Cumberland
  • Homes for sale in Indianapolis