19723 Atwater Avenue, Sheridan, IN 46069 · $445,413 · Sold

Here's 19723 Atwater Avenue in Sheridan, IN 46069. This listing is closed, but I can still walk you through the details.

1 photo from the listing — tap any to expand.

Showing 1 of 50 · 49 more loading.

Photo of 19723 Atwater Avenue, Sheridan, IN

Sold — 19723 Atwater Avenue, Sheridan, IN 460691 / 1

Quick read on the numbers:

$445,413$449,981

SoldNew construction

Beds

Baths

Sq ft

2,820

Built

2025

Acres

0.23

Here's what I think this home is worth:

FREE FROM SHELDON

Thinking about your next move?

Most people checking their own home's value are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — see how I price, market, and sell homes in Carmel and Hamilton County.

Explore selling with Ackee

Key things to know

Sold 3.0% below list in 98 days
New construction
Atwater subdivision

From the listing

Olthof Homes presents the Rowan. Discover this spacious 2820 sf home featuring 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms and a versatile loft perfect for extra living space or a play area. The main floor features a spacious bedroom with a full bath, perfect for guests or multi-generational living. The primary suite boasts a luxurious tiled shower, double sinks, and a walk-in closet, offering a private retreat. Enjoy the durability and style of the luxury vinyl plank floor in high traffic areas. With an open-concept design and a 2-car garage, this home is built for modern living and convenience. Don't miss your chance to make it yours! Olthof Homes builds high performance energy efficient homes with a third-party certified energy rating (HERS rating). 10-year structural warranty, 4-year workmanship on the roof, Low E windows, and Industry Best Customer Care Program.

A few highlights from the feature list:

Interior

Attic AccessBath Sinks Double MainKitchen IslandEntrance FoyerEat-in KitchenWired for DataPantrySmart ThermostatWalk-In Closet(s)

Exterior

Lighting

I'll break the details down — open any section that matters.

TAX ASSESSMENT

County assessed values for current year

Total Assessed Value

$413,700

Land Value

$98,000

Land$98,000

24% of total

Improvement Value

$315,700

Improvements$315,700

76% of total

This home has sold:

Sold

$436,505

-$13,476 below list (-3.0%)

Closed: Jun 20, 2025
Listed at: $449,981
Sold: 11 months ago
Sold in: 98 days

Price history

Sold$436,505
Jun 20, 2025
Price reduced$444,881 → $445,413
May 1, 2025
Listedat $449,981
Jan 31, 2025

Atwater · activity

past 6 months

Sold: 17
Median price: $335,000
Median DOM: 39 days

A few similar homes that recently sold nearby:

Recent comparable sales

Same zip · similar size

Comparative value

5 comps in this range

This home is 6.1% below median for similar nearby sales.

$335K$2.1MMedian $465K

$437K

A few places to dig deeper:

Atwater Westfield-Washington Schools

MLS# 22020308