1591 Preston Trail, Carmel, IN 46032 · $1,099,500 · Sold

New search

Here's 1591 Preston Trail in Carmel, IN 46032. This listing is closed, but I can still walk you through the details.

1 photo from the listing — tap any to expand.

Showing 1 of 43 · 42 more loading.

Sold — 1591 Preston Trail, Carmel, IN 460321 / 1

Quick read on the numbers:

$1,099,500

Sold

Beds

Baths

Sq ft

5,725

Built

1987

Acres

Here's what I think this home is worth:

FREE FROM SHELDON

Thinking about your next move?

Most people checking their own home's value are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — see how I price, market, and sell homes in Carmel and Hamilton County.

Explore selling with Ackee

Key things to know

Sold 5.6% below list in 24 days
Fireplace
Finished basement (1,055 sqft)
3-car garage
2-acre lot

From the listing

Nestled in the beautiful Crooked Stick neighborhood, this estate, set on 2 acres, offers incredible potential with TLC. The grand entry invites you into the home, showcasing expansive views of the private wooded backyard, open patio, and a peaceful gazebo, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The main floor features a spacious primary suite, providing a peaceful retreat. A charming den, adorned with distinguished wood paneling and a cozy fireplace, offers the perfect space for work or relaxation. The lower level is designed for both entertaining and comfort, with a wine cellar, open family room, and a versatile bonus room, complete with a full bathroom. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms, including a Jack-and-Jill bath and a guest suite with its own ensuite bathroom. With a little vision, this home offers the perfect canvas to create your dream living space in one of the most desirable neighborhoods.

A few highlights from the feature list:

Interior

Attic Pull Down StairsBath Sinks Double MainHigh CeilingsKitchen IslandEntrance FoyerHardwood FloorsHi-Speed Internet AvailblEat-in KitchenPantrySmart ThermostatWired for Sound

Exterior

Sprinkler SystemStorage Shed

I'll break the details down — open any section that matters.

TAX ASSESSMENT

County assessed values for current year

Total Assessed Value

$1,027,500

Land Value

$350,000

Land$350,000

34% of total

Improvement Value

$677,500

Improvements$677,500

66% of total

Annual tax · 2024: $17,050

This home has sold:

Sold

$1,037,500

-$62,000 below list (-5.6%)

Closed: May 27, 2025
Listed at: $1,099,500
Sold: 11 months ago
Sold in: 24 days

Price history

Sold$1,037,500
May 27, 2025
Listedat $1,099,500
Mar 31, 2025

Crooked Stick · activity

past 6 months

Sold: 7
Median price: $1,298,500
Median DOM: 5 days

A few similar homes that recently sold nearby:

Recent comparable sales

Same zip · similar size

Comparative value

5 comps in this range

This home is 16% below median for similar nearby sales.

$547K$2.6MMedian $1.2M

$1.0M

A few places to dig deeper:

Crooked Stick Carmel Clay Schools

MLS# 22028855